Yardbarker
x
One-on-One: Which NFL teams are most likely to go from lousy to playoffs?
Niners QB Jimmy Garoppolo and Jaguars QB Nick Foles. Scott Winters/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images and Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports

One-on-One: Which NFL teams are most likely to go from lousy to playoffs?

Yardbarker NFL writers Michael Tunison and Chris Mueller address some of the hottest issues in the league. This week's topic: Which team will be the out-of-nowhere or comeback playoff entrant in 2019?

Mueller: We've reached the soft portion of the NFL off-season schedule, the one between mini-camp and training camp. However, while this might be the last lull before things pick up to a fever pitch, it's also the perfect time to do some prognosticating. One of the most popular things to predict is which non-playoff team from the previous season will rise up and make it this year. Last season, the Texans went worst to first, the Colts went worst to second and made the postseason, and the Bears won the NFC North after spending 2017 in the cellar. Dallas, Seattle and the Chargers qualified after missing out, too. 

The surface explanation for all three turnarounds is clear. Deshaun Watson and Andrew Luck came back after missing part (Watson) or all (Luck) of 2017. Mitch Trubisky took a leap forward in Year 2 with Chicago, and the Bears' defense was a force. Khalil Mack made them dynamic and the Bears terrorized the division. 

Which team is poised to make it to the dance this year after missing out in 2018? I'll omit the Steelers and Packers because the argument seems too easy. Great quarterbacks rarely swing and miss two seasons in a row. The Browns feel too trendy and too talked out to name here, either.

That's why I'll go with the San Francisco 49ers. The reason is simple: They’ll get Jimmy Garoppolo back. The jury is still very much out on him, but he has a legitimate top-flight weapon in tight end George Kittle and a defense that wasn’t as bad as the points allowed in 2018 (435) suggest. San Fran was 28th in scoring defense, but 13th in yards allowed. Rookie defensive end Nick Bosa being around should help, provided he’s healthy, and the Niners gave Garoppolo some weapons in the draft in wide receivers Deebo Samuel and Jalen Hurd.

The Cardinals may struggle mightily again, and there could be a Super Bowl hangover for the Rams. Seattle looks strong, but the Niners start the season with Tampa Bay and Cincinnati, albeit on the road, and if they get out of the gate 2-0, belief could start building in Santa Clara.


Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports

Tunison: I'm tempted to take an AFC West team, but the division is so strong throughout, it makes such a positional turnaround exceedingly difficult. So instead I will go with the Jaguars. That's right, with not too much noise in free agency, a lot is contingent on Nick Foles for bringing them back to respectability, and frankly his playing style works well enough for them that I think it's possible.

He does a fine job of limiting turnovers (four picks in 195 attempts last season), and though he didn't exactly replicate his torrid 2017 postseason, he had a respectable follow-up effort and managed to win another playoff game, albeit on a somewhat fluky missed field goal. A lot of people thought Blake Bortles turned the corner after beating the Steelers in the playoffs and nearly taking down the Pats in the AFC Championship Game, but it turns out that was an aberration. He was back to classic Bortles last season, which helps to explain why he's now the backup for the Rams. Foles shouldn't try to be an Alex Smith-type game manager, though he is capable of striking a balance between a playmaking QB and a more conservative one.

Why there won't be immense pressure on him right away falls on Jacksonville's defense, which slipped at times in 2018 but still finished sixth in DVOA. They also added Josh Allen, he of the linebacking variety, in the first round, and he has all the makings of a dominating force. Because there's been such a top-heavy rush on quarterbacks the last few years in the draft, the top talent at other positions falls further than it perhaps should, meaning the Jags likely got tremendous value at the seventh pick. At the very least, there's no way Duke QB Daniel Jones (Giants) should have gone before him.

I'm not particularly wild about Jags head coach Doug Marrone, though the team bringing on John DeFilippo as offensive coordinator was an inspired move to complement Foles. The other three teams in the AFC South had winning records in 2018. That said, there's still no overwhelming force, leaving room for a surprising upstart to usurp the lead. 


Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports

Mueller: I wonder about executive VP Tom Coughlin’s influence on the Jaguars, and whether it could drag them down again or whether some guys just tire of the overarching tough guy militaristic attitude he favors. He might not be the coach, but his presence is felt, for better or worse. His comments in April about voluntary workouts angered the NFLPA, and probably didn’t do him any favors with Jalen Ramsey and Telvin Smith, the latter of whom evidently won’t be playing football this year.

Then again, I wonder if  Jags players would happily tolerate Coughlin so long as they had competent quarterback play. It seems like Foles will bring that to the table, but it bears mentioning that his entire body of work consists of one out-of-nowhere, incredible season and a memorable playoff run. He was good last year, but not great. Jacksonville will need him to be closer to the latter to surmount the Colts and Texans.

While we’re on the subject of franchise culture, the Niners have so far weathered any real controversy stemming from Bosa’s social media problems, with his teammates seemingly welcoming him with open arms, and Richard Sherman delivering a straight-forward statement on the matter.

If Bosa is as advertised and brings it on the field, San Francisco figures to dramatically improve its 37 sacks from last season, a mark that placed them in the bottom third of the league. Getting after the passer will be of added importance in a division that now has Kyler Murray (Cardinals) to go along with Jared Goff and Russell Wilson. Murray is a spectacular runner, Wilson a very good one, and Goff usually has the ball out before the rush gets to him. Find a way to make those guys uncomfortable and you’ll find a path to intra-divisional success.

Defense will be important for the 49ers, but in the end, the story of their 2019 season will be told by the answer to one question: Can Kyle Shanahan get the most out of Garoppolo? If he can turn Garoppolo into something resembling 2016 Matt Ryan, San Francisco will be a surprise and a force to be reckoned with.

Tunison: It's kind of amazing that five years into his NFL career, it's still hard to say with any authority how good Garoppolo is. The Niners went into last season with a tremendous amount of hype, and their season in effect was over by Week 3 due to a gruesome injury. In that abbreviated time, he didn't exactly look like a world-beater, and the injury happened on a play where, if he used better judgment, he could have avoided contact altogether. That he didn't, and now has to return from the type of injury that can sometimes require more than a year to get back to 100 percent, should be a cause for concern.

Foles has had something of a spotty career, but there's enough overall and enough recent success to think he can pilot a turnaround of a capable roster. Leonard Fournette missing half of last season to injury was something of a killer for Jacksonville, and he owned up to his part of that due to poor conditioning, which he has reportedly been working on this off-season. If there is a concern with the Jaguars offense at full strength, it's more the receiving corps than the quarterback, so Foles is going to need all the help he can from the established talent that's present.

The Jags have the Chiefs and Texans, 2018 playoff teams, out the gate. You might say that's a lot of pressure for a new face in a new place, but the first few weeks of the season are often deceptive, and good teams often haven't yet found their footing. Take, for example, the now annual September or October freakout about a single Patriots loss, only for them to make a run later in the season. It's quite possible, especially Week 1 at home, that the supposedly lowly Jags can catch Kansas City off guard. Taking down the Chiefs to start the season could be just the springboard back to relevance.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

+

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.